The Silent Killer in Plain Sight:
Reading the
Warning Signs in Your Cap Table
By Rafael Karamainan
Founder and Managing Partner at Lendity
A company’s capitalization table is way more than a mere spreadsheet, it’s the architectural blueprint of its financial future, a moral pact between its stakeholders, and the very DNA of its corporate body. It encodes not just ownership, but power dynamics, incentive structures, and future possibilities. At Lendity, when we underwrite companies for growth capital, this document is one of the first and most critical items we analyze.
Too often, what we find isn't a blueprint for a sound structure, but a design for a controlled demolition. Like a house built on a fractured foundation, these companies carry structural weaknesses that become apparent only when they try to scale or seek a sophisticated capital partner. This is the "broken cap table," and from our perspective, it's one of the most significant liabilities a growing company can have.
The Anatomy of a Broken Cap Table
A broken cap table rarely happens overnight. It’s the result of successive rounds of fundraising where short-term needs overshadow long-term consequences. When this DNA becomes corrupted, the organism itself becomes diseased. The symptoms are classic and devastating.
The Preference Stack Pyramid Scheme
Liquidation preferences were designed as investor protection, but in their extreme forms, they've evolved into something more sinister. Think of it as a Jenga tower: each new financing round with aggressive terms pulls a critical block from the base, leaving the entire structure fragile. This creates a "preference stack" pyramid, where founders and early employees sit at the bottom, crushed under the weight of accumulated preferences. We've seen companies where investors have 2x, 3x, or even participating preferences, the ultimate "double-dip" where they get their money back and a share of the remaining pie.
The result? A company that raised CHF 10 million with aggressive terms might need to exit for CHF 40 million just for common shareholders to see a dime. It creates a moral hazard where a modest but life-changing exit for the team is rejected because it doesn’t clear the towering preference stack.
Dead Equity & Dormant Stakeholders
A related symptom is the accumulation of "dead equity." This refers to significant ownership held by stakeholders who are no longer active in creating value, a dormant co-founder who left years ago, an early advisor whose contribution has long since passed, or an accelerator whose impact has faded. This dead weight not only fails to contribute to future growth but also demotivates the active team, who see precious equity sitting idle.
The Valuation Trap
High valuations feel like victories, but they're often worthless ones. That eye-watering valuation from your Series B might have impressed the press, but it also creates a ceiling your company must shatter before most stakeholders make money. We call this the "valuation trap": when your last round's price becomes a millstone around your company's neck, often forcing you to accept the aggressive preference terms mentioned above just to justify the headline number.
Gridlock by Veto and Fragmentation
Every investor wants a voice, but this can lead to two forms of paralysis. The first is the Veto Rights Gridlock, where we've witnessed boards paralyzed by overlapping protective provisions. One investor can block a sale, another can prevent new financing, a third controls key hires.
The second is a Fragmented Cap Table. If a company has dozens of small angel investors, achieving the consensus needed for critical decisions becomes an exercise in herding cats. This fragmentation, even without explicit veto rights, can create a de facto gridlock that slows the company down at the moments it can least afford it.
The Underwriter's Perspective: An Acid Test for Health
When we evaluate a company, we are fundamentally assessing its long-term viability. A broken cap table is a primary indicator of internal conflict and structural risk. Here are the key questions we consider, and that every founder should ask themselves:
Lendity Underwriting Acid Test
A clean bill of health on these questions signals that a company is built on a foundation of fairness and strategic foresight, qualities essential for sustainable growth.
The Path to Rehabilitation
A broken cap table, while damaging, is not always a terminal diagnosis. We recognize that sophisticated solutions exist. A full recapitalization can reset the structure, though it requires painful negotiations. Strategic share buybacks can clean up dead equity. In some cases, a new founder-focused ESOP can be used to re-incentivize a leadership team that has been overly diluted. Acknowledging that these paths exist is a sign of a company's maturity and its commitment to fixing its foundation.
The Importance Strategic Financing Choices
The path to a broken cap table is paved with dilutive funding rounds. This is why the choice of capital is so critical. While equity is essential for early-stage ventures, a relentless pursuit of it can lead to the very problems we've outlined. Strategic, non-dilutive capital allows founders to maintain control and preserve ownership for their team. It's a sign of financial sophistication and a commitment to building long-term, enterprise-wide value.
The Choice Before You
Every financing decision is a moral choice disguised as a financial one. You're choosing between preservation and dilution, between alignment and conflict. For founders who understand that ownership structure is destiny, there's a better path. At Lendity, we believe a healthy, aligned cap table is the ultimate indicator of a company built to last. It signals that the leadership values fairness and is focused on sustainable success—the very foundation upon which great companies are built.
Build smarter. Scale faster. Give up less.
Join 400+ founders getting our monthly insights on capital and growth.
Learn more about Funding Strategies
The Headcount Control Tower: How to Scale Efficiently by Tying Hiring to Revenue
Tag: Funding Strategies
The Capital Stack: A Guide Not to Accidentally Selling Your Entire Company
Tag: Funding Strategies
SeedStrapping: Why Your Next Round Might Be Your Worst Decision
Tag: Funding Strategies